The real finger of blame at Arsenal?

What would happen if Phil Collins and Paul McCartney did a duet of Hey Jude which then ran into In The Air Tonight? It would be played on the radio over and over and over again, and when that wasn’t enough, they’d perform the 37-minute live version at a Royal party.

Now, one of the few things that can be equally as painful is the realisation that no one is accountable for anything at Arsenal. In fact, mix it in with an interlude of fourth place is a trophy. It’s tired and it’s largely infuriating. But a lack of accountability from anyone at the club is at the root of the bigger problem.

Arsene Wenger will never give his players the public thrashing they deserve. Actually, it’s hard to imagine the manager parting with some strong words behind closed doors. But the players know that it will never come to that, the Arsenal manager is far to composed to be seen as a man who shakes the foundations of the Emirates. For that, the players are given a free ride, and one that can be stress-free if they have no intentions of winning or a desire to keep their pride intact—which arguably some don’t.

[post_link url=” https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/arsenal/finances-aside-this-could-be-a-good-thing-for-arsenal,https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/arsenal/saving-for-a-rainy-day-the-storm-clouds-are-gathering-at-arsenal,https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/arsenal/the-great-disappointment-for-arsenal-fans” target=”_blank” type=”tower”]

Wenger has continued to talk up Arsenal teams in the past as individual players and as a whole squad who are far better than what they are. Maybe it has something to do with the players going on to fulfil this potential which the manager is so confidently preaching. Yet when they look into their reserves, there’s nothing in the tank for them to even rise to the occasion of a singular and very straightforward game.

Maybe we should look at it as these players being good enough but not trying when it matters. After all, how many Arsenal players in the current team were what you’d call “terrible” players at their former club? Gervinho won a title at Lille, Marouane Chamakh has a league title from his time with Bordeaux and Sebastian Squillaci has league titles and a Champions League final appearance from his time in France. That’s only the players deemed “terrible,” what about the good ones?

But it’s an easy life when you can perform so badly and not have to answer to anyone. And that’s the point, no one needs to answer or even has an answer when Arsenal begin to tumble down the league table. There’s far too much protection at the club for people who should be accountable, yet Wenger—even with his own managerial flaws—remains on the front line and as the first and only line of defence.

It would be great if for a whole month’s worth of games—because once just isn’t enough—if Wenger laid into his players after a poor performance. Some will ask what good that will do, well not saying anything at the moment isn’t exactly bringing rewards. When the manager finds excuses like fatigue, poor playing conditions, referees, the rain ruining players’ perfectly gelled hair, it makes the players believe that they’re doing nothing wrong. Above all, it makes them believe that their current poor state is the zenith of their abilities.

Is it ok for Wenger to want this peaceful environment at Arsenal, one where no one screams at anyone else for lack of application? Not really, because it just amounts to poor preparation for real football matches. But then comes the stubbornness, and maybe Wenger has done enough in his career to warrant the chance to do it as he pleases, but there’s no doubt that he’s having to take the hit for players who consistently let him down.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

I’m all for the argument that some players are just not good enough for Arsenal, but none of them are beyond or above hard work and a little more application. If the perfect passes can’t be found, then run a little harder to win the ball back. Yes, all of these players are Wenger’s buys, no one at the club would force any player on the manager. But a large collection of performances by most of these players are enough to make you question whether they’re even Premier League quality, let alone good enough for a team challenging on four fronts.

It’s the way it is at Arsenal and it will remain so until someone openly speaks about the damaging state the club are in. The squad as a whole may not be good enough, but their performances are reflective of the laid back attitude from the highest point. It’s unfortunate, however, that Arsene Wenger takes the heat from both sides’ failings.

[ad_pod id=’xmas’ align=’center’]

Scott Parker back in contention for Spurs

News of Tottenham Hotspur’s Scott Parker returning from injury has given Andre Villas-Boas a boost ahead of their Premier League game against Everton on Sunday.

Parker, 32, has yet to feature for the Lillywhites this term and hopes to be back in contention after a lengthy spell on the sidelines brought about by an Achilles operation in August.

Returning to action during a 5-1 defeat to Ipswich for the reserves at Spurs Lodge, the midfield stalwart completed a vital 90-minute’s and signalled his readiness for first team contention.

AVB will now monitor his progress to decide whether the Spurs man deserves a prolonged run in the first team. With Sandro impressing defensively, and scoring a 35-yard goal against Fulham last week, Tottenham now have a healthy selection headache ahead of their trip to Goodison Park.

Harry Redknapp is also keeping tabs on Parker and will be looking to swoop in for his former player if he is deemed surplus to requirements at White Hart Lane. Redknapp is in desperate need of steel in the middle of the park and sees Parker as the inspirational leader that QPR lack.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

The player now has two and a half years to run on his current contract at the Lane following a £5.5million move from West Ham United last August.

A Football Agent’s View – ‘Inside the transfer window’

There is no question that Agents make the footballing world go round and at this time of the year, on the verge of the much vaunted transfer window, they are more important than ever. They will be the men behind every deal that’s made over the next month and whatever your opinion on them, they could be the difference between your club signing the player that catapults you to glory or condemns you to relegation.Here we talk to football agent Simon Dent about how the transfer window works and what to expect over the coming weeks.-Is it a myth that the January window is a bad time to do business – or just an excuse?As an agent it allows us to focus our winter business but its not ideal. Prices are driven up and a false economy is unfortunately created. The one plus for clubs is that in January they can take a view on how the season is going and what they need to get them through until the end of the season.-Is a January window actually good for football, or does it encourage panic buying?I don’t think it helps the clubs but for the supporters its a month that provides excitement, hope and certainly in the last 24 hours a lot of entertainment.-Which clubs are likely to be the most active in the January window?This January I think that QPR, Liverpool, Chelsea, Spurs, Man City and Reading will be most active on the permanent moves-Which deals are likely to happen in the January window?The big moves I can see happening will involve Sturridge, Anelka, Sunzu, Zaha, Ince, Huddlestone, Ba, Walcott, Robbie Keane, Wanyama and Donovan. I imagine the total spending will hit around £50million with the majority of this being spent by 3-5 clubs.-Who are the best bargains to pick up in the Premier League this January?T Huddlestone, S Kalou, C Gordon, T Walcott, F Lampard and M Fellani will be be great additions to any clubs on the look out for a good deal in January.-Will the loan market be the most active out of the two?Not so much in the Premiership but I can see a lot of players from the Premiership being loaned to the Championship and the Championship to League One.-What impact will the financial fair play rules have on the Premier League club’s spending?Unfortunately I think these regulations may be toothless when crunch time comes. Clubs are already being very creative about incomes genreated so in answer to the question I don’t think spending will be curtailed at all. Simon Dent is the Managing Director of ROAR Sport (www.roarglobalsports.com)

Arsenal consider move for Argentine ace

Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger has set his sights on deals for Lucas Biglia, according to reports from The Mirror.

The Gunners chief is keen to bolster his squad in an attempt to secure a top four finish, and qualification for the Champions League.

Anderlecht’s Biglia is thought to be his top target, after the Argentine admitted that he is looking to move on.

Newcastle and Norwich are also thought to be looking at the deep-lying playmaker, but it’s thought that he would favour a switch to North London.

Wenger is also said to considering Wigan’s James McCarthy and Mohamed Diame of West Ham, but favours Biglia due to his range of passing.

Napoli winger Vargas has previously been on the Frenchman’s list of targets, with his the Italian club believed to be willing to allow him to leave in January on loan.

The 23-year-old Chilean was once dubbed one of the rising stars of world football, but has struggled for game time in Naples of late.

He is comfortable playing in a wide midfield position or just behind the main striker, which would allow him to fit into Wenger’s first-team plans.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Meanwhile Fulham are confident of agreeing a loan deal with Andrey Arshavin, who has been strongly linked with Reading.

[cat_link cat=”arsenal” type=”grid”]

Southampton v Manchester City – Match Preview

It was at this point last month, guided by Nigel Adkins, that Southampton were finally starting to look like an accomplished Premier League team and building up a steam in their survival crusade. Fast forward to the present and Mauricio Pochettino is now at the helm having sensationally replaced Adkins at St Mary’s less than a month prior prompting widespread surprise and condemnation for the Saints board. Its fair to say that the South Coast club have found it tough going under Pochettino thus far, failing to win in the three games since his arrival. But if there is one thing the Argentinian excels at it is pushing clubs to punch above their weight, something he achieved at Espanyol, and to his credit Southampton have moved the ball better in recent weeks, especially against Wigan when they deserved to leave the North West with more than a share of the spoils. But with Pochettino and the club still tangled in a sticky transitional period the last team they’d want to face is title chasing Manchester City.

This has been tagged as a must win game for City by manager Roberto Mancini after he watched his side fall nine points behind leaders and local rivals Manchester United last weekend. Defending the title they won in dramatic circumstances last May has left the champions running on empty and it’s hardly a shock that they find themselves playing catchup on United. Offloading Mario Balotelli to Milan last month has put the onus on Sergio Aguero, Edin Dzeko and Carlos Tevez to fire City back to the top-flight summit. They proved last week that there is still enough left in the tank to challenge when coming from behind to snatch a point from Liverpool, stretching their unbeaten run to eight games, while Aguero’s breathtaking equaliser exemplify’s the present abundance of quality at the Etihad Stadium.

Team News

Luke Shaw and Nathaniel Clyne are both doubs after withdrawing from the England under-21 squad in midweek. Gaston Ramirez and Guly do Prado are also struggling to be fit in time.

Yaya and Kolo Toure are back from African Cup of Nations duty, while Vincent Kompany and Maicon could be available.

What the managers said…

“We played games in which we have deserved to get more points than we have done, but I think the way we are approaching games and playing are the way in which we will start to pick up points. All of our matches are difficult in this division, but we know that Manchester City were the champions last season so we will need to be at our best to beat them. For me, Manchester City are a great team with great individual players and they can decide a match on their own.” Mauricio Pochettino believes Southampton deserved more from his first three games in charge (sainstsfc.co.uk)”Manchester United have done better than us this season because they won a lot of games. They have nine points more than us. But if we can recover eight points in six games, recovering nine in 13 games will be easy. I never remember the title race being finished 10 or 13 games before the end. Three years ago Chelsea were nine points behind at one point. By the time they played at Old Trafford two or three games from the end, they were only three points behind. In the end, if Manchester United win all their games from now to the end of the season, they deserve to win. But I am sure we have another chance.” Roberto Mancini maintains his side can claw back the nine point gap held by Manchester United (Manchester Evening News)

Pre-match Fact: Southampton striker Rickie Lambert needs just one more goal to bring up his century for the South Coast club.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Prediction: Southampton 1-3 Manchester City

Is he entitled to greater security at West Ham?

The relegation battle in the Premier League is far from over, just yet, but there is the strong inclination that West Ham have done enough to be safe from danger.

Sam Allardyce’s contract at West Ham is set to expire in the summer though. David Gold and Sullivan have insisted that they will sit down and discuss new terms in May but does the former Bolton and Blackburn boss deserve better? Or is this a rouse to move the 58 year old on?

A spiral of uncertainty now swirls around Upton Park as Allardyce has insisted he wants to thrash out new terms as soon as West Ham are mathematically safe. You can hardly blame him considering the nature of his departures from football club’s in the past.

Should Gold and Sullivan make the situation more comfortable for all involved and sign Allardyce to a new contract as soon as possible? If Big Sam is to remain at the helm surely he will need to make plans for the development of the team going into next season for the transfer window, long before May.

At this moment I want to point back to the 10 point pledge the West Ham owners made to the fans in May 2010 going into the 2010/11 season. It was as a signal for how they planned to lead the club the success.

The first point on this list was to appoint the right manager. The season after this checklist was made West Ham were relegated and the Allardyce reign began. He achieved promotion at the first attempt and now looks intent on achieving survival in his first Premier League campaign for the Irons. If this is not the qualities of the right manager for the job then it is difficult to quantify what is.

They went onto mention in this pledge that they would listen to the supporters too. Whilst you will never see all the West Ham supporters advocate the methods of Allardyce they would surely be in agreement Premier League football is a priority. It is useless playing pretty football next season if they are to get relegated to the Championship.

The eighth point of the plan is the one which may draw contention as it was to make football enjoyable for people to come and watch. This is where the Ownership at Upton Park seemingly have a get out of jail free card to dispense of Allardyce’s services using this as an excuse. Would that be acceptable? Definitely not.

It appears to be quickly forgotten at times that Premier League football is a results business. Arsenal have regularly played eye catching football yet still disappoint their supporters. Swansea would not be lavished with praise for their style of play, in the manner they have been this season, if they had not achieved Capital One Cup glory. The Gold and Sullivan partnership may want to be careful what they wish for in their handling of their current boss. The grass is not always greener.

If there is any hesitation as to whether they should be handing their man a new contract they want to read their own words they wrote in 2010 at the end of their 10 point pledge.

“We are here for the long term and our goals will evolve as we progress. We are proud to be here and will never stop working for you.

“All of us share the same hopes and dreams. It is not just about aiming for cup finals or derby victories but about feeling part of something together and all pulling in the same direction.”

If Allardyce is for the long term this may be a worry, but surely for now they have to, as they state above, progress. There may be a leader in the future in the mould of Di Canio who can deliver the glamour football required but for now stability is essential.

West Ham should have enough this season to survive but achieving the same feat two seasons running would be a greater achievement. There may be plans for the Olympic Stadium and continued development in various aspects but ensuring consolidation on the pitch is what remains most important.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

If fanciful thoughts have suddenly struck Gold and Sullivan to try and quietly relinquish the duties of Allardyce then the Hammers may be the latest club to be struck with the curse of sacking him too soon.

Whilst Allardyce is by no means entitled to contract security in the nature Pardew was awarded at Newcastle, it is time for the sensible decision to be taken at Upton Park.

If the plan does though suddenly evolve and a new man is handed the reins to lead West Ham into battle then you wonder whether there really is a plan in East London after all.

[post_link url=”https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/southampton/chelsea-or-arsenal-who-would-represent-the-ideal-move, https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/queens-park-rangers/is-qpr-merely-an-audition-process-for-him, https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/west-ham/the-10-greatest-west-ham-wags-of-all-time, https://www.footballfancast.com/premiership/west-ham/sam-allardyce-worried-about-west-ham, https://www.footballfancast.com/football-news/west-ham-set-sights-on-manchester-united-outcast” target=_blank” type=”grid”]

There is now a truth to ‘boring, boring Arsenal’ – but is it a bad thing?

Last season, Arsene Wenger was able to rely on Robin van Persie in order to form a late charge on the top four in the Premier League. This season, the Arsenal manager may be holding another ace up his sleeve – except we won’t really know how influential it is until sometime in May.

That’s the erratic nature of football –or is it fun? Being able to make a bold decision one week which swings the entire season in your favour when the game looked up. But Arsenal has needed to go back to basics when all hope seemed lost. The traditional Arsenal we’ve known under Wenger has been done away with and a defensive game has been adopted.

It’s a sad state when it’s come to this: a club who have long been considered the most attractive football team in England having to resort to a ‘back-to-basics’ approach. But Wenger should receive plenty of praise for having the ability to once again potentially turn this whole thing around. Well maybe not quite unwavering admiration. After all, this is Wenger’s team that he’s assembled. These are players who were identified as good enough for his brand of football by a group of scouts under his watch. For all the attention to detail and the meticulous building of this football club under Wenger, I fail to believe that his scouts haven’t been drilled in properly identifying players who are good enough for Arsenal.

It’s been far too long since Arsenal have played that free-flowing football that was once described as “from another planet” by van Persie. It’s been too long since a sustained period of time in a campaign was built on the theme of irresistible football and a style of play that genuinely was stunning.

In truth, it wasn’t too long ago. The last time Arsenal had a fantastic football approach to their game was the 2010-11 season, where one of the highlights of the campaign saw a commentator describe the team’s winning goal as a “Barcelona goal from Arsenal,” when they defeated Pep Guardiola’s side at the Emirates.

But the swing in approach and quality has been too quick and too severe. Wenger made a late dip into the transfer market for a group of players who really weren’t suited to his ideals of the game. You have to ask sometimes whether the manager is consciously buying pieces to a puzzle or if he’s just snapping up what’s available at a decent price.

When Arsenal made the call to Everton and eventually sealed the signing of Mikel Arteta, did Wenger really intend for the Spaniard to play as the team’s holding midfielder? Surely not. Surely most were right on the money when it was assumed that Arteta was the replacement for Cesc Fabregas, albeit one who was nowhere near the same class in terms of quality and ability.

So if Arsenal’s last two games – two 2-0 wins away at Bayern and Swansea – are a conscious effort to turn things around, why has it come so late?

Wasn’t it fairly obvious that there were not enough players in this team to play the style of football that was most recently executed by those headed by Fabregas? Santi Cazorla and Arteta, and then only some way into this season did Jack Wilshere appear. It wasn’t enough and the tactical approach – if we’re going to call it that – wasn’t suitable to what was on offer. You then go back to the question that has been asked countless times: is Wenger making the most of what he has at his disposal?

But this different approach has been a long time coming. Players like Aaron Ramsey and Carl Jenkinson are far better at getting ‘stuck in’ and rolling up their sleeves than they are at imitating Barcelona or Ajax. Sure, Ramsey could become one of those players in the future, but with a whole team and club down on confidence, the only option Wenger had was to take a far more basic approach.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

I don’t believe all of Arsenal’s good defensive work over the past two games has solely been linked to the absence of Thomas Vermaelen. Per Mertesacker stated over the weekend that the team were analysing their defensive performance against Tottenham with a view to improving. Mertesacker, notably, is a defender who stays deep and denies the opposition space in behind. Recent performances completely fly in the face of those who have said the German is one of the worst defenders in the league. The point is, even the very best will be made to look like amateurs if they’re used in the wrong system.

Now, it’s very difficult to know what exactly goes on inside the walls of London Colney, and most of what is said by outsiders is largely speculation. But when have you ever heard of Wenger instructing his coaches and players to go over the tapes of recent performances with the intention of eradicating mistakes? The Arsenal manager always seems to be about sending his team out to win at their own game first, rather than countering the threat of the opposition. If Wenger really is taking this on board, then it couldn’t come soon enough.

[opinion-widget op width=”full”]

West Brom duo set to move on

Chris Brunt and Goran Popov have been ruled out of West Brom’s clash with lowly Wigan at the Hawthorns on Saturday.

Baggies skipper Brunt will miss his second successive game after picking up a knee injury in the 1-1 home draw against Newcastle a fortnight ago, while Popov is missing with the calf problem he picked up ahead of last week’s 3-1 win at Southampton.

And, while they will definitely not feature against Latics they have an outside chance of lining up against Manchester City on Tuesday evening.

Boss Steve Clarke will be boosted by the fitness of James Morrison despite him limping off at St Mary’s with 12 minutes remaining because of a slight groin injury.

Defender Craig Dawson is back at the club following a successful loan spell with Championship promotion-hopefuls Bolton Wanderers and Youssouf Mulumbu is also available for selection again after completing a three-game ban.

However, Marc-Antoine Fortune, who was sent off at Southampton last weekend, will serve the first match of his three-game suspension.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

[cat_link cat=”west-bromwich-albion” type=”grid”]

Should Everton be considering such an appointment?

Although there appears to be a unanimous consensus that David Moyes was rightfully appointed as the next Manchester United boss, being in style, nationality and manner a natural successor to Sir Alex Ferguson, there is still a hint of sadness and sympathy regarding the Scot’s decision to leave behind his former club, Everton.

Being a distant admirer of the Toffees and a self proclaimed Everton enthusiast, in no small part due to their continual defiance of resources and finance, there is a concern that this will be the end of the Merseyside outfit as we know it, with a number of the club’s key figures, namely Marouane Fellaini and Leighton Baines, being linked with moves away from Goodison Park in the summer, in addition to David Moyes’ tenure being an incredibly difficult act to follow.

[cat_link cat=”everton” type=”tower”]

It could well be a turning point for better or worse in the club’s history, and success and failure over the course of the next few years at Goodison will undoubtedly depend on Bill Kenwright’s next managerial appointment. Whilst a number of British-born candidates have been shortlisted for the role, including Malky Mackay, Neil Lennon and Phil Neville, there are also a fair few foreign managers being considered by the Everton chairman, such as Roberto Martinez, Gus Poyet and Porto’s Vito Pereira, who over the past few days has become one of the front runners according to the bookies.

It begs the question as to whether Everton should go British or foreign with their next appointment, and what implications it will have for the club on and off the pitch in the years to come.

Foreign managerial influence is rife in the Premier League, and I would argue that overall the English top flight is much better for it. The type of football we have witnessed from Swansea and Wigan this season, taking clear influences from the styles and in the former’s case the personnel of La Liga, has been enriching and fantastic to watch, creating fixtures between clubs of sharp contrast with typically English teams such as West Ham, Stoke, Sunderland and Norwich.

Both philosophies of play have their strengths and weaknesses, yet it has undoubtedly improved the English game in general, and even our bigger clubs such as Chelsea, Tottenham and Arsenal are now geared towards a more technical approach to their game.

Although other clubs such as Newcastle have been accused of their foreign influence taking away their identity, Swansea, Chelsea and Arsenal are all glowing examples that importing a style of play from outside of the English game can work if conducted effectively, and should Bill Kenwright appoint Roberto Martinez or Vito Pereira, you’d feel that both managers have enough ability, vision and proven track-record to make Goodison Park a fortress of continental flair.

Yet the transition to such a manner of play will undoubtedly take time, considering that David Moyes’ tactics and roster have been geared for over a decade towards playing the game in the English way – a combination of height, strength, power and ability on the ball to get results. Of course, it all depends upon the summer’s incomings and outgoings on the blue half of Merseyside, but you cannot imagine the likes of Marouane Fellaini, Victor Anichebe, Phil Jagielka or Johnny Heitinga readily and quickly adapting to a style of football that is South American or Spanish in its origins.

Furthermore, it is time that Everton arguably don’t have. I don’t wish to be accused of ‘scare-mongering’, but the fact is that the scope for failure is incredibly slim at Goodison Park. The finances remain continually tight, and with the summer marking the end of an era for the Toffees, one bad season or a false start could easily lead to a downward spiral for the club. David Moyes has already had the club and the players performing to a level beyond their means for some time, and any disruption to the squad’s intense bond, with the first team clearly better off as a whole in a well-oiled machine rather than being significantly talented as individuals, could trigger disaster.

Similarly, as mentioned previously, much has been made this season about striking the balance between home-grown talents and players imported from abroad. Currently the Toffees have 12 players in their registered 25 man squad born within the British Isles and Ireland, whilst many others, such as Tim Howard, Steven Pienaar, Victor Anichebe and Sylvain Distin have plied their trade in England for such a long time they have practically become English by association.

Everton’s successes under Moyes has been in no small part due to the roster’s overall strong familiarity with the style, quirks and methodologies of the Premier League, and should a new foreign manager come in, ripping apart this integral core to make space for flashy foreign footballers from abroad would almost certainly constitute as a grave error, favouring idealism over pragmatism.

But whether the next manager will undergo a policy of evolution or revolution will not necessarily depend on their nationality; Gus Poyet and Roberto Martinez may both hold foreign passports, yet both have spent the majority of their playing careers and the entirety of their management careers in England.

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

At Brighton and Wigan respectively, both have struck a balance between English physicality and South American flair, and given time they could replicate their feats at Everton. Despite the number of big lumps in the Toffees’ roster, there is similarly a contingent of players that possess no particular athleticism, but rely upon their technical abilities and more importantly their footballing brains, such as Steven Pienaar, Leighton Baines, Darron Gibson and Leon Osman.

Whether Bill Kenwright appoints a foreign manager or not, the key will be to provide longevity rather than bringing in a manager for the short-term. You’d argue that in terms of vision at least, thinking Spanish or continental would therefore be the way forward, as Roberto Martinez has proved during his tenure at Swansea and the legacy he left behind, that installing an ethos and philosophy creates a long-term success that surpasses the stay of any particular manager or player, no matter what their ability.

But in terms of consistency from one term to the next, it would appear that choosing a manager whose ideology is British in origin outweighs future visions of the club in terms of importance. There has always been a level of pragmatism and reliance upon knowledge of the English game behind David Moyes’ successes, and with the scope for wholesale change reasonably limited at Goodison Park, the next appointment does not have to be a carbon copy of the former Everton boss, but at least must share with him similar values.

Everton have an English core, English style and English identity, and foreign or not, the incoming manager must not compromise these pillars of the club’s triumphs over the last decade, however there are grounds to make subtle modifications and improvements to them, taking lessons from a more continental approach to the game.

Time to assert his authority at Manchester United?

David Moyes would have been naïve to believe he would be afforded an easy ride in the first few weeks of his new job at Manchester United. The world of football slows down for no man, and this is exacerbated when you are taking over the reigns from one of the most successful managers in history. Juggling the status-quo and the establishment of a new era for the Premier League club, Moyes must get a hold of things quickly if he is to succeed.

The first few weeks for David Moyes at United have been something of a roller coaster already. I can only liken it to a teenager being given the keys to his dads bright red Ferrari. Previously used to his own beat up Clio, of which he had total control over its simplistic  inner-workings. The new motor offers up unparalleled complexities and the poor kid is apprehensive to do anything of note apart from messing about with a few of the dials. Thus far Moyes seems cautious to make any big calls and decisions.

On the transfer front this is perhaps unsurprising. Previously used to a shoestring budget at Everton, Moyes is being opened up to a world of riches that he could only have dreamt about. Spending a decade looking at making low end transfer steals cannot prepare you for the deals he must make at United. This explains why the usually decisive Scot has favoured talking about transfers and speculating rather than appearing an integral part of any deal. Speaking on United’s pre season tour to Asia he appeared distant from any negotiation:

“I think a point does come. But when you are interested in good players you want to give it every opportunity to materialise.”

“I will hope things will continue to move forward. I can only tell you Ed Woodward is working hard to try to make the deals happen. We hope some of them will fall into place shortly.”

Now don’t get me wrong in this day and age it is not usually the job of a manager to directly negotiate deals for players. However, what would be expected is that the manager is key to any decision regarding player recruitment. Currently there is a strange pattern emerging where Moyes appears to be totally removed from any transfer deal, happy to talk and speculate rather than get anything done.

Do United not trust him yet, or does he not trust himself? Clearly the transition from Everton was never going to be easy, but the Scot really does need to assert his authority quickly within the club.

He appears to be a rabbit in the headlights not only in terms of incoming players but also outgoing. The Rooney saga spiralled from his description of the player as being “second choice”. He of course followed this with talk of the value of Rooney to the club and how important he will be next year (something which many people have glossed over). Still for someone who rarely gives much away in press conferences, this represented something of an unnecessary gaffe by the new manager. He moved quickly to diffuse the situation by assuring that Rooney is not for sale. Speaking at a news conference in Sydney, the United boss said regarding Rooney:

“The club’s position has not changed.”

This is an example of how the Scot is already finding it hard going to fill the shoes left by Sir Alex. Rarely indecisive at Everton, he now appears apprehensive in his media handling and this should already be a worry for United fans.

It would be unfair to judge a new manager only a few weeks into the job, especially since they are yet to play a competitive game. Indeed I would echo the words of the departed Sir Alex when he urged fans to offer their unwavering support to the Scot. It is easy to forget what a difficult start he had to his now extraordinary reign at the club. However, Moyes seems overly nervous upon taking over the helm. Speaking to the Guardian, he was happy to openly admit to butterflies:

“Yeah, that comes with the excitement of the job. It’s more to do with the magnitude of Manchester United and following arguably the greatest manager that football has ever known”

FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast. FootballFanCast General Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.


By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.

Butterflies are one thing, but to appear in fear of the task ahead should be something quickly removed from the mind of the Scot. Moyes never appeared to be a manager short on self-confidence, but his start at United seems to suggest the contrary.

David Moyes is an excellent manager, he has proved this previously and he will no doubt do it again. He needs to approach the United job believing that he is the man to take United on to the next level. To do this he needs to start being assertive in the way he approaches the media, his squad and new transfers. There was never going to be a honeymoon period for Moyes at United. Instead of playing around with his new Ferrari in the drive, he needs to kick it into gear and take it out onto the open road.

Do you think Moyes needs to show more confidence at United?

[cat_link cat=”manchester-united” type=”grid”]

Game
Register
Service
Bonus